Explainer
Free speech web hosting: what it means and who offers it
Free speech hosting is web hosting from a provider that won’t take a lawful site down just because someone complains. It is a policy choice of the host, not a legal shield, and the law of the server’s country still applies. Here is what it covers, what several hosts actually write, and our own policy.
Free speech hosting means a host that decides on complaints by the law, not by pressure or its own taste: lawful but unpopular speech stays up. It does not make illegal content legal. Constitutional speech rights limit governments, not private hosts, so what protects a site is the host’s written policy and the law of the country its server is in.
What “free speech” protects, and from whom
- United States. The First Amendment begins “Congress shall make no law… abridging the freedom of speech”. It limits what governments may do; a private hosting company choosing what it hosts is making a business decision.
- Europe. Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights protects freedom of expression, but its second paragraph allows restrictions “prescribed by law and necessary in a democratic society”, for example to protect the reputation or rights of others.
- Iceland. Article 73 of the constitution states that everyone shall be free to express their thoughts and bans censorship, with restrictions only by law and for listed reasons.
So “free speech hosting” is about the host’s behaviour: whether a complaint alone is enough for it to remove your site.
What makes a host speech-friendly
- Who decides on a complaint, and on what basis: a court order, the host’s reading of the law, or simply the complaint.
- The jurisdiction of the company and of the server, since that law decides what is lawful.
- A written procedure: what happens when a notice arrives, and whether you are told and can answer.
- What is banned anyway: every host bans some things, and the list should be short and specific.
What hosts actually publish
| Host | Where | What its own pages say |
|---|---|---|
| NearlyFreeSpeech.NET | United States (New York area) | Operates under US law; follows the DMCA process but removes only the specific material named, and a complaint alone is not termination |
| OrangeWebsite | Iceland | Does not respond to DMCA takedown requests; removal needs an Icelandic court order; cannot protect customers from prosecution in their own country |
| IncogNET | Finland, Netherlands, United States | Supports free expression and stays apolitical; customers must follow the speech laws of the country where their service runs |
| Orielhost | Iceland, Netherlands, Romania (company in Panama) | Foreign copyright notices get no response; decisions follow Panamanian law; the law of each server’s country still applies at its data center |
Our policy
Criticism, journalism, satire, activism and unpopular opinions are welcome on Orielhost. A US DMCA notice or another foreign copyright notice gets no response from us: Goatprod LLC is a Panamanian company and follows Panamanian law and Panamanian court orders.
The servers sit in Iceland, the Netherlands and Romania, so the courts of those countries and, in the Netherlands and Romania, EU rules on hosting still reach the data centers. Spam, phishing, malware, attacks, fraud and child sexual abuse material are banned and lead to suspension. The full rules are in the acceptable use policy.
The limits everywhere
- No host is outside the law. A court with authority over the server, or over you, can still act.
- Defamation, threats and incitement are illegal in most countries, whatever the host’s policy.
- Your own country applies to you even if the server is abroad.
If staying online matters, combine a speech-friendly host with a private payment and a careful setup: the anonymous hosting guide.
A host is only one layer
A site can be cut off at several points, and the host is only one of them. When Cloudflare explained in 2017 why it dropped a client, it listed registrars, hosts and DNS providers among the companies that hold a site up, and wrote: “Any of the above could regulate content online.”
- The domain can be suspended by its registrar or registry, whatever the host decides.
- DNS and CDN providers can stop answering for the domain.
- The data center and its network answer to the law of their country.
We cover the hosting layer. Choose your registrar as carefully as your host, keep a copy of the site off the server, and keep your DNS somewhere you can change quickly.
Questions
Is free speech hosting legal?
Yes. Choosing a host with a strict complaint policy is legal; the content itself must still be lawful where it matters.
Does the First Amendment stop a host from removing my site?
No. It limits governments. A private host can choose what it hosts, which is why its written policy matters.
Is free speech hosting the same as DMCA ignored hosting?
They overlap but differ: free speech is about lawful speech in general, DMCA ignored is about US copyright notices. See our DMCA notice policy.
Why Iceland for free speech hosting?
Its constitution bans censorship and removal decisions go through Icelandic courts. See Iceland web hosting.
Sources
- First Amendment, US Constitution Legal Information Institute, Cornell
- Guide on Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights European Court of Human Rights
- Constitution of Iceland (Article 73) Constitute Project
- NearlyFreeSpeech.NET FAQ NearlyFreeSpeech.NET
- Freedom of Speech Amendment OrangeWebsite
- What is your stance on free speech? IncogNET
- Why we terminated Daily Stormer Cloudflare
Lawful speech stays up
Hosting paid in crypto, no ID, servers in Iceland, the Netherlands and Romania.